I don't expect any less from a guy with 2 chick names... what a chicken shit puss.. he's what is wrong with the NHL and why it's becoming WWE..

Both of these guys have no punching power, can't wait to see Big Mac destroy these two numnuts

Wait Shelley was bleeding? Shocker

Shelley is never going to learn until they send him on a vacation for a long time. He keeps doing the same thing he did it last year several times he keeps hitting from behind because he is to stupid to stop. Someone will do it to him before he gets the message. Taken to many punches to his head for sure.

both landed some but just danced when they became tired.

a draw a 7 shelley is a sucker punching cheap piece of shit who now stoops to hitting from behind.

Glad they made an example of Smelley. 10 games and he has to explain to his wife/kids why he won't be getting a paycheck for a few weeks.

Shelley didn't even hit Boyce that hard, who should have been more aware of whats going on anyway, what's Shelley supposed to do, not finish his forecheck? As for the fight, good even tilit, call it a draw and 7

Draw all the way.

Rosehill early, Shelley earned a draw by sticking with it and landing the last good one.

Rosehill earns his money, but a draw. For those who think Boyce should have been more aware, trust me, he was. Why do you think he chipped the puck one way and headed the other? Shelley should have been more aware! Aware that the NHL is cracking down on those hits. Aware that there is a new disciplinarian in town. Aware that he is the perfect player to set an example with....

a prime Shelley hurts Rosehill. steal any hookers cars lately Jay ? they used to hang horse thieves.

draw or edge rosie

I see Rosehill graduated from being an AHL punching bag. Good job Rosie. Cant stand either one of these jokers but fair play for him sticking up for his team mate. Cheap dirty hit by Shelley, should be suspended and fined for sure.

Great fight I call this a Draw for the reasons that rosehills best punches and punch that opened shelley up was in that early surge when shelley wasnt really set Once shelley got set, he seemed to control the rest of the fight moreso than rosehill and they both landed real good ones

Shelley - Rosehill is nothing but a minor league punk

Edge Shelley

Very slight edge to Shelly who was on the attack the entire fight. Players used to scoot in and move the puck on the fly or at least draw up their shoulders to protect themselves. Now they are going to drift in and put their faces to the boards and look as unprotected as possible to try and draw a penalty. It looks like Boyce was daring someone. A few hits like this early in the season and the ensuing headache will be useful in reminding the shirkers that this is still a contact sport and not tiddleywinks.

Ah, the enigma known as Jody Shelley, feeling the pressure of Tom Sestito as the new team enforcer along with a fat contract that if jettisoned would get the Flyers below the cap. So he makes a bonehead move by crunching the Leafs player from behind into the boards, earning himself a major and a game misconduct, probably a suspension. Then Shelley gets opened up a la Chuck "The Bayonne Bleeder" Wepner by Rosehill but manages to eke out a win with a couple of heavy belts to Rosehill's mug. Today I suspect that Paul Holmgren is sitting there trying to figure out what to do with Jody Shelley.

Good fight with an edge to Shelley.

I am giving a slight edge to Shelley. You can see blood on Shelley right off the bat when Rosehill just came up and punched him. IMO the fight hadn't even started yet so I'm not counting that. Even though he deserved it. Shelley got the slight better of Rosehill.

Shelley with a slight edge. Rosehill stood up for his teammate and does alright even cutting him but in overall Shelley got the better of the two.

Judge the fight, not the hit. Shelley.

If Rosehill didnt puss out the first 2 times shelley tried to fight him then Boyce wouldnt have gotten boarded. Draw, although Shelley did look tougher.

this scrap was all jody shelley.

THE FLYERS DIDNT TAKE LONG GETTING BACK INTO THE SWING OF THINGS-THROWING CHEAPSHOTS AND THEN BEING UNABLE TO HANDLE THEMSELVES IN A FIGHT-mid season form already

Way to stand up to Jody Shelley!!!

Shelley breaks Boyce's nose, Rosie cuts Shelley's brow. How an instigator was awarded I can't see.

Was one of those do it and you are suspended hits... Good Scrap and i think Rosehill fought a smart fight and won that one with the heavier blows...

Rosehill with the easy win here...pounding away on 58 year old block head Jody Shelley.

Shelley is washed up. He should have been able to pound "Roseypalm", but to no avail. Rosenmeister with a narrow win.

Slugfest, I give Rosehill the edge

Good scrap which Shelley won most of......but that big bomb gives Rosey the close win. 7

Started with a hit from behind by Shelley on Boyce. Rosehill asked, and Shelley obliged. Rosehill started with lefts, Shelley with rights. Both fighters landing solid,quick punches rock em sock em style, back and forth. Rosehill landed the better punches cutting Shelley above his right eye. Nod goes to Rosehill but a good, close fight. 7.

Brutal hit by Shelley who deserved to answer for it. Rosehill starts off well with the lefts but things even out once Shelley sets up. Rosehill takes this on by landing just a few more but only just....still not convinced Rosehill is a true heavyweight but we shall find out this year with Orr still on the shelf...

Good job of Jay

Win rosehill, there was a great left that cut open Shelley's eye and he did enough to get the W IMO. Hopefully Rosey gets the nod this year as he brings great energy to the leafs.

Rosey!!! Orr had better kick some @ss tonight, or he may be losing his job. Rosehill with the win. Great fight.

Win Rosehill. Not sure what fight the Shelley voters are watching... probably just Leaf-Haters being the bitches that they are.

how could anyone vote for shelley??? at the start,rosehill was punching shelley in his face and shelley stood there like wondering what's goin on...strong win rosehill

"that push from behind" ???? Who are these jackass announcers? I am BY NO MEANS a Leafs fan but that hit was exactly what this game doesnt need! And Shelly is a REPEAT offender! The guy deserves a stiff suspension and these idiot announcers should be fired. In terms of the fight. Rosehill land the better punches and opened up Shelley! Win Rosehill.

Nice tilt, close, but the edge to Rosehill on quality landings as Shelley threw some big shots but didn't land anything spectacular.

Edge Rosie. Great scrap, good job fellers. Keep up the good work. 8.

Good job Rosehill! Enjoy ur suspension Shelley u cheap piece of garbage

rosehill gets the win in this fight.

It is always nice to see someone get tuned up and bloodied after an obviouls cheap shot. Win Rosehill by a drip of blood or two.

Another in a long line of goons from Philly who need to be removed from the game. Hope he gets a season off.

Rosie with the the most shots connecting, and drawing blood. Close, by Rosie by a bloody nose.

Pretty good back and forth fight. In the end Rosehill bloodied Shelly and won the fight. Hoping to see more from Rosehill and the rest of the Leafs this season!

Gotta give the win to Rosehill, for the simple fact that he stood up for a teammate. plus, he bloodied Shelley, great scrap though

great fight rosehill early and late shelley in the middle

Good job by Jay stepping up for a mate !

Easy win for Rosie.

Thatta boy rosie. good fight for a good reason and rosehill gets the win. For any that say he didnt look whos leakin at the end

decent fight for preseason! draw/edge shelley IMO

Good bout...Allday draw

How f#%@ing hard is it to NOT lower your shoulder and ram someone from behind into the boards. Do the jersey's need stop signs like midget hockey? Good long scrap afterwards, 7 draw, but wish rosehill would have KO'd him.

StacyB has it right about Shelley, but I give it a draw as Rosehill held his own and was able to draw blood

Cheap hit.......Thats a suspension!!!! Plain and simple ....Now the fight....Rosehill did what he needed to do and stood in there but IMO Shelley is just a tougher dude and when they are going toe to toe you can see that he's better stronger and more comfortable doing it Win to cheapshot dude

I didn't see Shelley land many shots so it's hard for me to see how anyone could give this one to him. His last punch looked like mostly shoulder to me.

Close givin to Rosehill cuz he cut um open. DUMB hit by Shelley.

Good close tilt, edge to Rosehill.

Nice bit of enforcing there by Rosehill, the more i see of this kid the more i like. Orr and Rosehill would be a nice 1-2 punch.

Easy win for Rosehill

Another American Philly pussy trying a rear end low hit gets nailed.

Nice job by Rosehill stepping in for a teammate.Flyers announcers are complete assholes.They say Shelly gave him a shove.No assholes he drove him into the boards.I know Shelly isnt known for his on ice skills other than with his fists,but dont remember him being a dirtbag.I guess putting on a Flyers jersey does that to you.