Two talented but very annoying players square off. Slight edge to the bigger Perry. Shaw's melt down in the box later in the game was classic.

When douchebags collide.

Shaw tries, but keeps getting jersey pulled over his head, Perry looks amused while Shaw flails like a girl. emekin, shaw, wow pathetic small team, not gonna win in the playoffs with midgets, didnt they learn yet ??

My hopes went up when Shaws head got covered up and the punches continued :o

Well, I was hoping to see that weasel looking Perry get his pointed nose broken. Unfortunately Shaw was not able or capable of getting the job done. I called it a draw. Maybe someone else will get a hold of Perry and fulfill my xmas wish list. Kind hard because Perry is good at picking his spots. He does not take chances with someone of equal size or fighting ability.

i dont know.perry was more active but he is much bigger and i dont think shaw felt his pillow punches and perry had a couple opportunities to finish the fight but didnt...draw

W Perry (3)

Perry is twice the size and comes out with a draw. Score that for Shaw. More heart more the winner

Winner Corey Perry.

Y

Pers should of done better here. Had the jersey over Shaw's head and had him setup plush for a pummeling. Not sure what instigated this maybe something left over from the Chicago days.

A little back and forth Fisticuffs ensue Perry starts well with Shaw gaining ground in the middle Perry coming on strong in the end. edge Perry1

Looks like a few of those landed. While not a great fight by any means, I think it garners more than a 2.9. I rated it a 4 and the win to Perry.

Perry locked up Shaw but did nothing with it. Shaw worked hard to throw punches with Perry just holding on....nothing landed...Draw,

Unfortunately, these 2 turds didn't beat each other unconscious. Also, is it just me, or does Perry start this thing by trying to slew foot Shaw prior to the fight?

Shaw has to be the fakest tough guy in the league.

Perry uses his size and reach advantage to outpoint Shaw in this scrap.

any time Perry gets his due I'm a happy guy and could he punch any slower?

Perry with the marginal win. Really wish he could have connected a few more times Shaw was such an awful signing

Katy Perry lookin' for the linesman to step in ... too funny !

I've seen Perry make dumber decisions when he's not scoring...

The easiest fight Perry has ever been in... WIN Perry though the Brigade de Toilet Seat will call it for shaw

How in hell does Perry have any votes here....although he doesn't do much more Shaw clearly wins this ......big size advantage and he does nothing with it .......win for Shaw scored it at 3......in this a fight for the most detested both are winners.......

Nothing better than a couple of shit disturbers slapping eachother

Like him or not, Shaw taking Perry off the ice is a win. Not so much fight wise but Shaw always lets you know he's there

The Fairy only picks the big guys to dance with.....

Andrew Shaw is unable to beat down Corey Perry. Absolutely sad.

shaw cant even beat katy perry , and he is there tough guy , I bet the montreal faithfull are real impressed!

Perry goes and validates the entire concept of Andrew Shaw by taking 5 minutes with him, while forgetting that he once failed to administer a beating to Pavel freaking Datysuk. The loser is hockey.

You gotta hand it to Shaw, he's a small guy but he hangs in there. If he was as big as Perry he would have beat his ass