Billy G. rocks but this scrap he loses.

i dont know.guerin landed two good punches but i give it a draw

very close....draw

HEY MISS YA GUERIN, BUT WITH THE YOUTH MOVEMENT...HE HAS BETTER SHOT TO GET A RING NOW! HE WAS GOOD WITH THE ISLES AND CAN STILL FIGHT AT HIS AGE. WAY TOO GO IN THIS NOT SO GREAT OF A FIGHT! LETS GO ISLANDERS!!!

Draw. It was as if Clarkson became mesmerized by the stick movement (after the ref licked it away), which allowed Guerin to (justifiably) land a couple of smacks, but that last shot by Clarkson seemed to connect with something.

DRaw

young guy simply asking an old tough guy to go.

DRAW......Have to hand it to Billy G. for standing in there with a stronger and younger kid,hes never shyed away from any tilt.

good for guerin! i say draw..i do like clarkson,but i know he would not go with goddard

Guerin was going pretty good landing a couple of solid shots.. but in the end Id say a draw with a slight edge to Clarkson for knocking Guerin down/off balance. And kudos to Guerin for still being willing to get in there and throw with a much younger and experienced (as far as fighting goes) guy.

Clarkson asking Guerin if he was ok at end was a class act.

Guerin has always done it all. As a Bruin fan I always dreamed of a line consisting of ... LW- Tkachuk C- Roenick RW -Guerin Jeremy Jacobs had different dreams...$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ Fight was a draw. Guerin landed more, but when you go down just as the other guy is starting to respond I can't give you the win.

DRAW or Edge BG. He out-threw and that last shot from Clarkson doesn't even come close to landing, it glances off the helmet. Look closely and you'll see it's pretty clear.

Guerin with the slight win. Guerin does this because he is a hockey player you jackass!

Close fight. Guerin landed more but clarkson had the big one in the end.

Guerin gets the nod, more punches landed. Devils are not the bad boys they once were. Pens are making a statement every where they play. I agree, if Goddard had been in the lineup, Clarkson wouldn't have even tried. What a punk Clarkson is, if he wanted a fight, why didn't he pick one with a fighter? Orpik would have ended his season for him.

Guerin gets the edge. As has be said elsewhere, Guerin did NOT go down at the end because of a Clarkson punch, he slipped.

win to guerin he landed better shots.clarkson'spunch never realy laned it was cleary more of a slip then anything..win guerin!!!

not much there, but Guerin landed the only punch I could see

guerin got in a few shots, clarkson did not knock guerin down, he slipped.

Not sure how Clarkson comes out with the victory here when Guerin connected more. No respect for a player that picks a fight with a 38 year old that did nothing wrong but skate with a team that had a five goal lead in the third. Too bad Eric Godard was a scratch. Clarkson could have taken a mushful from him for his honor.

Guerin got in more shots, but that shot he took at the end kinda evened it out. Kudos to the old guy though

I've watched this fight now 5 times and don't see clarkson land more than that one at the end .. and it was a glancer... Eh.. down 5 goal.. what else can you do..

Guerin has balls for taking on the younger guy plus landed some nice shots

Gurein in a close one. Last punch by Clarkson hit Guerin on left shoulder pad.

guerin gets a good one or two punches in but clarkson wins by tko. but great respect he had for guerin at the end there. not really sure why guerin was fighting anyway. i've seen him fight on the islanders when emotions are high, but just like that?

Chico Resch swallows... Not sure if clarkson knocked him down or he slipped but either way you have to give clarkson credit for knocking him down.

not too much going on in this fight.

I'm a Guerin fan, but I had to give the win to Clarkson. A draw seems fair as well, but I saw Clarkson having the edge.

Kudos to Guerin but when you get dropped, you lost. Clarkson looks like the POS after this one.....

Might need a slow mo of this one to see where that last Clarkson punch connected. Guerin fell down like he was hit on the button but it looks like it hits his shoulder pad. Hmmmm....fishy. I'll give it to Clarkson for now.

oooo...sorry Bill.

Clarkson gets the W for the bomb at the end

Props to Clarkson for not drillin Guerin on the ice

Sad to see Guerin go to the Pens. Guerin is a good player who isn't a pu$$y, he doesn't fit in with the rest of the Pens.

Guerin didn't do too bad for an old guy that doesn't fight much, still the W is clearly Clarkson's.

guerin got good shots in at the beginning, but when your knees buckle like his did at the end from that shot, can't give him the win. W clarkson. always liked guerin though.

Winner Clarkson. Guerin is pass his prime for fighting. He was great in his day.

solid right by Clarkson. Gets the dub.

I like watching veterans like Guerin fight, it honestly show they are still genuine hockey players as opposed to someone close to retiring. Way to go Guerin, although win goes to Clarkson.

I love Guerin, always have, he's a good old time hockey player, a little past his prime now, but I love how he always played, would score and hit and throw the mitts down when he needed to, and was never dirty. Just an all-round great hockey player. Huh, well now that I've left my review for Guerin, I called this fight a 6, and an edge to Clarkson, I certainly don't think that last big shot is what put Guerin down, but I still figure he landed more.

Clarkson only lands one but it was the only one that matters.

Guerin started well but Clarkson appeared to be waiting for the right time. I still can't see how that punched floored Billy but clearly it must have been a clean shot. Win to Clarkie. I love how Guerin gives the kid props on the way to the box.

What morons put Guerin as the winner...he was KOed you idiots. Clarkson clearly won this...it was as obvious.

Great job by both, Clarkson is one of the best middleweights and gets the TKO

The younger Clarkson too strong for the veteran Guerin but kudos to Guerin for getting in there and throwing.

Guerin fell down and landed more shots, but with an end like that you have to give it a draw

Guerin landed a nice shot at the onset but Clarkson landed a couple of decent ones to take the win. I think Guerin slipped more than he was knocked down at the end. How refreshing to see someone start something and finish it as opposed to the way that punk Avery behaved the other night.

Clarkson wins it.

Clarkson gets the win, but Guerin landed a few at the start.

Win to Clarkso, but its always great when Billy Guerin steps up

HTF can one vote for guerin? Clear loss.

guerin was doing really well til that last shot

Nice fight for guerin but the last shot by clarkson earned the W. Props to guerin for fighting a guy like clarkson.

im a huge Billy G fan....but DC TKOd him with that shot....a 6

WIN CLARKSON

Now that the Pens have Guerin they have the missing character piece and are winning. I don't know why they don't score 5-6 goals every game. Anyway, Win for Clarkson since his knockdown didn't look like slip to me.